So this questions comes up a lot when women talk to me about a guy they may have dated and things didn't seem to work in the romance department, but they wanted to remain friends with the guy instead. They mention how maybe they weren't attracted to him physically "that way" or maybe she wasn't ready to commit yet and she just wanted to "be friends". Yes, the dreaded, F-word! So allow me to answer the age old question.
So can a man and woman REALLY be friends?
This is a tricky question. Even I, who has had a very close friendship with a man, am not 100% sure what it takes to be friends with a guy or vice versa, friends with a girl.
Many things have to come into play. I will try to break them down one by one to make sense and in doing so, you'd have to ask yourself a few questions.
1) Is the man or woman you want to be friends with physically attractive to you?
2) Have you too ever been intimate together?
3) Does one of you still see yourself dating and being with the other person?
If you have answered "yes" to any or all of these questions, then most likely "No, you will not be able to JUST be friends with this person." But there ARE exceptions.
Allow me to explain.... again....
First, if you find this person to be physically attractive (and of course, if they find you to be physically attractive) then it is highly unlikely "just friends" would ever work. And with that, is the question "Have you ever been intimate together?" Don't get me wrong, it IS possible to be attracted to someone and NOT have sex with them, but it is also REALLY hard. Men, based on fact, think about sex more than women but don't forget women think a lot about sex too. And if you are physically attracted to someone AND you have already been intimate with them, BINGO, then you both will most likely not only be able to be "just friends". It is pretty inevitable.
With that said, comes the last question "Could you see yourself being with this person?" If you can see yourself with them on more than a friend level, but on a dating/marriage level then you are more than friends or being "just friends" with this person will be nearly impossible.
But remember it is possible to be friends with someone of the opposite sex, because there are exceptions to every rule. But please understand this is extremely rare.
These are some of the exceptions to the rule.
1) If you have already dated this person, either just once or for years, friends is something that will NOT be possible right away. I have never known a split up couple to be friends immediately following a breakup. It can take weeks, sometimes years for this to be possible, but it can be possible. Give it tem years, you are both now happily married, with kids.... sure, friends COULD be possible.
2) If you have already had sex with this person (a friend or ex), you have pretty much walked down a dead-end road. There is no way to act as though it never happened and no way to take it back. An important fact that will never change is : SEX CHANGES EVERYTHING! Period. Once sex comes into the scenario, your friendship will never be the same at least not for awhile. Same goes for if you were intimate together in the past. You will be able to be friends after this, but mostly likely many many years down the road.
3) Is this person in a relationship? Are you? Are your significant others "okay" with your friendship with this person? Usually more often than not, they are NOT okay with it. Hence, drama or struggle in the friendship which can cause the two of you to have a difficult, if not impossible friendship. And it's the world we live in most of the time. A world full of affairs, divorce and being untrusting. You can blame Desperate Housewives, EVERY single day-time soap opera and the high divorce rate for this. Unfortunately we live in a time that accepts a happy divorce as much as happy marriage.
So I guess the real question is "What makes a friend?"
Webster defines it as "One attached to another by affection." While Wikepedia defines it as "Mutual understanding, mutual compassion and the tendency to desire what is best for the other." From experience I can say that I have had friends, or should I say acquaintances that I considered friends, and I didn't trust them nor did I feel there was mutual compassion. This would be of course a one-sided friendship. This occurs often when a friendship is based off of one person of each sex. But, again, there are exceptions.
So the bottom line is this. Men and women CAN be friends but it's like a one in million, needle in a haystack sort of friendship. It takes A LOT of work, A LOT of understanding and absolutely NO tension, sexual or otherwise.
So, if you are friends with someone of the opposite sex (and I mean AS CLOSE to them as you would be to your best friend of the same sex), then I give you massive kudos. Not only have you achieved an amazing friendship, but you have also pretty much done the impossible.